Keys, for most people: one key produces one correct note, so the first satisfying sound arrives in minutes rather than weeks. Guitar takes longer to sound good and is more portable and more sociable.
Why keys are the gentlest start
No intonation to learn, no fingertips to toughen, and a correct note on the first press. Progress in the first month is visible.
Why guitar is still the most popular
It is portable, it accompanies singing naturally, and three chords cover an enormous amount of music. The first few weeks are less rewarding.
The honest advice
Pick the sound you want to make. Every instrument is easy at first and hard later; only wanting it gets you through the second part.
The questions players ask
What about drums?
Physically the most immediate and the hardest to accommodate in a flat. A mesh-head electronic kit and a riser solve most of that.
Does the easiest instrument matter?
Less than motivation. The instrument you actually want to play beats the one that is technically easier, every time.
Last reviewed 2026-08-19